next up previous
Next: Acknowledgements Up: No Title Previous: Grain-size evolution in a subducting slab

Discussion

The present results provide also some insight into the possible mechanisms of deep earthquakes. Deep earthquakes are believed to occur as a result of instability of deformation in the ductile regime, and it has been argued that deep earthquake activities are related to the transformation of metastable olivine to modified or spinel phase [1,23]. The nature of instabilities associated with the olivine-spinel transformation appears to be fundamentally different between the warm and cold branches of the kinetic phase boundary (branches ``A'' and ``B'' shown in Fig. 2). Our results suggest that instabilities will occur only when the transformation occurs in the cold branch ``B''. The effects of grain-size reduction to cause softening and hence instability will be important only in the cold branch because significant grain-size reduction occurs only at relatively low temperatures.

Checking the applicability of the ``standard'' thermal assimilation model [22,24] for the occurence of deep earthquakes with seismological observation, Kirby [25] found that variations of maximum intraslab earthquake depths with slab thermal maturity (the thermal parameter) are too complex for the description with this simple model. Instead, he and other authors argued (see e.g. Bebout et al., [26]) that the metastable persistence of olivine may cause a nonlinear declination of deep earthquakes depths in dependence of the thermal parameter. Here, we partly confirm this hypothesis by plotting the location of the metastable olivine wedge in the coldest part of subducted slabs vs. the thermal parameter, Fig. 4.



Figure 4

Depth of metastable wedge vs. slab thermal maturity for different slab thicknesses (60-100 km) and different slab velocities (4, 7, and 10 cm/yr). Also shown is the compiled data by Kirby [25] of maximum (diamonds) and next maximum (circles) intraslab earthquake depths. Note the reasonably good correlation of both plots.


Since there are still large uncertainties in the kinetic parameters underlying the thermo-kinetic model, the quantitative details of the size and location of the metastable olivine wedge should be taken with caution. Despite of this, there seems to be a quite reasonable correlation of the geometry of the metastability region with the depth of the deepest earthquakes in several subduction zones.


next up previous
Next: Acknowledgements Up: No Title Previous: Grain-size evolution in a subducting slab
Michael Riedel
1999-01-27